“ Consistently good pizza - and probably the best pie in the area. Prices are reasonable too. ”

“ I've had their chicken and pasta dishes many times and they were very good. I recently tried their pizza and the cheese pizza needed to be cooked a little more but the buffalo chicken pie was cooked perfectly. ”

“ I order delivery from Mario's all the time, and every time the food arrives nice and hot, fresh, and always on time, and can I also add their food is great. Every year on December 24, I do the seven fishes for Christmas eve, the only thing I do not cook is the calamari, I purchased the calamari from Mario's. I order 1/2 tray of Fried Calamari, to be delivered at a specific time, and every year that tray arrives at the exact time that I asked Mario's to deliver. That half tray of Fried Calamari, arrives piping hot, as if it was fried in my own kitchen, it is also breaded to perfection, and that half tray, is totally full of calamari. It comes with plenty of lemons, and abundant amount of marinara sauce on the side. I believe I give the driver a nice tip. Wish him Merry Christmas. ”

“ Just got our pizza, a wonderful Sicilian Vegie pie. My family love it! I wanted to express my gratitude to the chef and the whole team whose skills and service truly made our meal unforgettable. it's one of the best pizzas we ever had and really reminded me that's the reason we get our our pizza here at MARIO'S! Please keep up with the GREAT JOB! David ”

“ An absolute classic restaurant that satisfy all cravings when you want Italian food. The cheese pizzas were delicious with the crust being crunchy and on top of that with ample sauce and cheese. The rigatoni alla vodka was very tasty and I loved how they gave lots of sauce, so that we could dip our garlic knots in it. The service was great where they delivered us our food to our table and the wait was not very long. One of the workers also helped me pack my leftovers to go and cleaned our spot right after we left. Ambiance was great for a Sunday night with lots of customers ready to indulge in some pizzas and pastas. Loved to see it and will definitely be back for more. Food: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 5/5 ”

“ I only come here when we're in town visiting family and this is my most favorite place for Grandma pizza. It's always served hot, fresh, and crispy. The staff here are always super friendly. Other things I've enjoyed here are their ziti and chicken roll. Can't wait til I'm back again... ”

“ Since I left NY for SF, good pizza and Italian American food is probably what I crave most. And within that genre, eggplant parm hero is the item I enjoy the most. A good eggplant parm hero is hard to find, even amongst the thousands of pizzerias in NY. The best eggplant hero has multiple layers of fried eggplant. In between each layer should be a thin layer of marinara sauce. Top with cheese and stuffed in a good hero bread and then broiled to gooey perfection. It's hard to eat this without burning your mouth because you just can't stop after each bite. The eggplant parm hero at Marios is pretty good, but needs more sauce. They give you 4 layers of eggplant, which is awesome. And there is an ample amount of cheese. If there was more sauce, it would be the holy grail. ”

“ Marios has the freshest pizza even after 9pm. Everything is fresh, the store os clean and the pizzas keep getting better snd better. They are so cool staying open an extra ten minutes and just made two special slices fresh. They are always generous and friendly. ”

“ Really, really good pizza. First timer here who had heard so much about Mario's and the Greek family that owns it. Well I was the recipient of tremendous Greek and International love, hospitality and lovely food in a warm and family atmosphere at Mario's Pizzeria on Jericho Tpke in Syosset. This is a warm, inviting and immaculate restaurant in a small busy shopping center smack in between the Syosset Hospital and S Oyster Bay Rd. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, a video ten thousand. Please check out the four videos of the gorgeous food plus a couple of photos of the extensive menu. The staff is absolutely stellar - the young ladies at the counter, the kitchen staff in the back and the lovely folks who are constantly clearing and cleaning the tables up front. Smiles galore and just warmth and how I can be of service oozing from all. Mario's features some great appetizers, healthy wraps, salads, hero sandwiches, pizzas, pasta dishes, calzones and some pretty awesome desserts. ( chocolate mousse cheesecake and the cannoli were stellar). They do a lot of catering and the takeout is non stop. I enjoyed sitting inside and dining and can't wait to come back. You have got to stop in and taste this amazing fare. Mario's is about a half a mile west of the 135 Hwy on the south side of Jericho. ”